Thursday, January 21, 2016

Re-Read: The Jane Austen Book Club


The Jane Austen Book Club by Karen Joy Fowler

Goodreads Summary:
In California's central valley, five women and one man join to discuss Jane Austen's novels. Over the six months they get together, marriages are tested, affairs begin, unsuitable arrangements become suitable, and love happens. With her eye for the frailties of human behavior and her ear for the absurdities of social intercourse, Karen Joy Fowler has never been wittier nor her characters more appealing. The result is a delicious dissection of modern relationships.

Dedicated Austenites will delight in unearthing the echoes of Austen that run through the novel, but most readers will simply enjoy the vision and voice that, despite two centuries of separation, unite two great writers of brilliant social comedy.

What I Remember:
Since reading the book in 2006, I have watched the movie many times. It's one of my fall backs when I'm looking for a good chick flick. I probably watch it about once a year. I was very surprised when I started reading to see how different the movie is from the book. I basically remembered nothing from the book version of this story.

My Original Rating:
I read this book before I started using Goodreads to rate books, but it must have been at least a 4 since I kept it all these years. I planned to read it again. Although until now I don't think I ever did. Probably because the movie came out, and I watched that instead.

My Thoughts on the Book:
I really like the characters in this book. But that's basically all there is...a lot of characterization and back story, not a lot of plot. I liked that the book was written in the royal "we". And I did enjoy how each month focused on a specific character (whoever was hosting that month), but until the last two chapters there just wasn't enough action in the present day story.

I am very impressed with how true the movie is to the original characters and story even though the movie changed a lot. The characters ages were all adjusted (except Prudie). But the movie writers were able to take all of the interesting bits about the characters and pull them into the main plot line. I have to say it: I like the movie so much more than the book.

Of course I love the Austen elements of the story. Although I really should read all of the books. I probably would have enjoyed the bookish discussion more if I was intimately familiar with the book details.

My Re-Read Rating: 3 stars

My Thoughts on My Original Rating:
I read this book when I was still a fairly recent transplant to Milwaukee and shortly after we'd bought our new house and moved to a different suburb. All that to say I didn't have a lot of friends. Around that time I also tried starting a book club, which wasn't very successful. I think I loved this book so much in 2006 because of the friendships and the book club aspect. I know I was drawn to it because of the Austen theme, but in that time of my life I think the characters appealed to me a lot despite the lack of plot.

Favorite Quote:
"The great thing about books was the solidity of the written word. You might change and your reading might change as a result, but the book remained whatever it had always been. A good book was surprising the first time through, less so the second."

The Verdict:
I'll be donating this book to the library. I think I'll stick to the movie in the future.

This book was read as part of my 2016 re-read challenge.

6 comments:

  1. I actually haven't read this or seen the movie. It doesn't happen often but sometimes the movie can be better than the book. I'll stick to the movie on this one :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The movie is such a great feel good chick flick. Check it out. And skip the book. :)

      Delete
  2. I love Jane Austen so much and I've read all her novels, but I've never ventured into anything Austen related beyond her own writing. I found an entire list of Austen-ish titles on goodreads - https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/405.Best_Jane_Austen_FanFiction

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I need to check out that list. I love Austen fan fiction! Thanks for sharing. :)

      Delete
  3. I haven't read this one in a long time but I love the movie! Really cool feature to re-read and re-rate a book from a long time ago! Great review!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Eva. I'm using it as a way to clear some old books off my shelves. I'm trying to re-read one old book per month this year.

      Delete